Boxing Forum - Boxing Discussion Forums banner

1 - 6 of 6 Posts
G

·
Discussion Starter #1
In my fantasy world there would a round robin tournament between the top 6 welterweights (by my account). What do you think the results would look like after it was all said and done? Let's say all the fights could happen over a month, the order was random and everyone would be at 100% and at the top of their game for each fight. I figure there are so many different opinions about 147 it'd be fun to see where everyone stands. Plus, I can't get enough of 147.

CONTENDERS
Paul Williams
Miguel Cotto
Antonio Margarito
Joshua Clottey
Andre Berto
Shane Mosley

Williams V. Berto - Williams KO in round 8 - Williams overwhelms Berto.
Williams V. Cotto - Williams KO in round 10 - Williams too quick for Cotto to run from.
Williams V. Margarito - Williams MD - This one could go either way. I like Williams hand speed and reach.
Williams V. Clottey - Williams UD - Close fight but Williams reach is the difference.
Williams V. Mosley - Williams UD - Mosley won't be able to avoid the output of punches.
Mosley V. Margarito - Mosley UD - If Cotto can outbox Margarito for 10 rounds, I think Mosley can do it for 12.
Mosley V. Berto - Berto MD - I think Berto is quick enough and strong enough to make Mosley uncomfortable.
Mosley V. Cotto - Cotto UD - Although some people thought Mosley won round 1, I still like Cotto.
Mosley V. Clottey - Clottey UD - Too big and strong.
Cotto V. Berto - Cotto UD - Too much experience for Berto to handle.
Cotto V. Margarito - Margarito KO in round 9 - Cotto put out his top performance in Marg-Cotto 1.
Cotto V. Clottey - Clottey by UD - Clottey's defense presents Cotto with a big problem.
Berto V. Margarito - Margarito KO in round 8 - Berto's lack of defense will land him on his back.
Berto V. Clottey - Clottey by KO in round 12 - I think Clottey dominates the second half of the fight.
Margarito V. Clottey - Margarito MD - This one could go either way. I like Margarito's chin.

My Results
Paul Williams (5-0 2KO)
Antonio Margarito (3-2 2KO)
Joshua Clottey (3-2 1KO)
Miguel Cotto (2-3 0KO)
Andre Berto (1-4 0KO)
Shane Mosley (1-4 0KO)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
88 Posts
Good idea, here's my picks.

Williams V. Berto - Williams TKO 11
Williams V. Cotto - Cotto MD
Williams V. Margarito - Margarito UD
Williams V. Clottey - Williams UD
Williams V. Mosley - Mosley UD
Mosley V. Margarito - Draw
Mosley V. Berto - Mosley UD
Mosley V. Cotto - Cotto UD
Mosley V. Clottey - Mosley TKO 12
Cotto V. Berto - Cotto KO 3
Cotto V. Margarito - Margarito UD
Cotto V. Clottey - Cotto SD
Berto V. Margarito - Margarito KO 7
Berto V. Clottey - Clottey UD
Margarito V. Clottey - Maragarito UD

Antonio Margarito (4-0-1 1KO)
Miguel Cotto (4-1 1KO)
Shane Mosley (3-2 1KO)
Paul Williams (2-3 1KO)
Joshua Clottey (1-4 0KO)
Andre Berto (0-5 0KO)
 

·
Calvarez
Joined
·
7,453 Posts
In my fantasy world there would a round robin tournament between the top 6 welterweights (by my account). What do you think the results would look like after it was all said and done? Let's say all the fights could happen over a month, the order was random and everyone would be at 100% and at the top of their game for each fight. I figure there are so many different opinions about 147 it'd be fun to see where everyone stands. Plus, I can't get enough of 147.

CONTENDERS
Paul Williams
Miguel Cotto
Antonio Margarito
Joshua Clottey
Andre Berto
Shane Mosley
Williams vs. Berto - Williams TKO9 - Berto too green.
Williams vs. Cotto - Cotto UD - Cotto outboxes him.
Williams vs. Margarito - Margarito UD - Margarito won't make the same mistakes twice.
Williams vs. Clottey - Williams UD - Williams has to much reach advantage.
Williams vs. Mosley - Williams SD - Close fight, but again Williams uses his reach to win.
Mosley vs. Margarito - Mosley SD - Could go either way. Shane in his prime is a class apart.
Mosley vs. Berto - Mosley UD - Berto too green still. Mosley a class apart.
Mosley vs. Cotto - Mosley SD - Could go either way.
Mosley vs. Clottey - Mosley UD - Too quick.
Cotto vs. Berto - Cotto TKO11 - Cotto has too much experience. Berto too green.
Cotto vs. Margarito - Cotto MD - I'm going for the upset. This time Cotto goes 12 and gets a decision.
Cotto vs. Clottey - Cotto UD - Outboxes him for a 12 round decision.
Berto vs. Margarito - Margarito TKO7 - Margarito wears him down and knocks him out.
Berto vs. Clottey - Clottey KO9 - Clottey too strong.
Margarito vs. Clottey - Margarito UD - Same as the first fight.

My Results
Shane Mosley (4-1 0KO)
Miguel Cotto (4-1 1KO)
Antonio Margarito (3-2 1KO)
Paul Williams (3-2 1KO)
Joshua Clottey (1-4 1KO)
Andre Berto (0-5 0KO)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,041 Posts
My Results
Paul Williams (5-0 2KO)
Antonio Margarito (3-2 2KO)
Joshua Clottey (3-2 1KO)
Miguel Cotto (2-3 0KO)
Andre Berto (1-4 0KO)
Shane Mosley (1-4 0KO)
I don't even need to look at the matchups to know that with that list of guys, there's no way P-Will makes it out undefeated.
 
G

·
Discussion Starter #6
Well, if this were to actually happen, I'm sure he would not go undefeated. However, I'd take Paul Williams at 100% over any of the other guys at 147 at 100%. So, that's how I arrived at 5-0.
 
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
Top