Floyd is good maybe even great, but won't deserve a PFP ranking in the history books if he never fights anybody. He's looked impressive against second tier opposition his entire career. Several guys have beat up on all of his top name victories and they're not called pound for pound? If he retires now we'll never know. If the best name on your record is Jose Luis Castillo and you couldn't even knock him out in either fight, then NO, you will never be one of the all time greats. He has always taken fights that he could win easily and never challenged himself when possible like against Antonio Margarito. He'll never take that fight because there's a good chance he'll loose. We shouldn't be encouraging fighters who fight safe Like Floyd and want to be taken so seriously.