[TommyGunn]

ok guys.

ive came to one logical conclusion how we can judge how great our greats really are.

we judge them on who they have beaten!

I'll start, please everyone name 3 names of each of your greats records and then if anyone would like to compare then they can add 3 names from another they think could rival....

ok, i'll start with the heavyweights. muhammad ali (AKA THE GREATEST).

just to add, all 3 are regarded as top 10 punchers ever.

LISTON
FRAZIER
FOREMAN

 

[bill1234]

Does it have to be heavyweight? If it doesn't,

Sugar Ray Leonard:
Roberto Duran
Thomas Hearns
Marvin Hagler

All 3 are considered P4P elites and hardest punchers

 

[TommyGunn]

Does it have to be heavyweight? If it doesn't,

Sugar Ray Leonard:
Roberto Duran
Thomas Hearns
Marvin Hagler

All 3 are considered P4P elites and hardest punchers

if you name a fighter nobody can compare another from the same weightclass unless they can top it.

 

[LeedsLad]

This game died:laugh: How about The Executioner....

Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Winky Wright

Looks excellent on paper

 

[TysonJones]

Roy Jones:

Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Antonio Tarver
John Ruiz ( heavyweight champ )
Felix Trinidad ( coming soon )

And my argument for tito is that if hopkins gets credit for it, so should jones.

 

[Ultimateboxa]

ok guys.

ive came to one logical conclusion how we can judge how great our greats really are.

we judge them on who they have beaten!

I'll start, please everyone name 3 names of each of your greats records and then if anyone would like to compare then they can add 3 names from another they think could rival....

ok, i'll start with the heavyweights. muhammad ali (AKA THE GREATEST).

just to add, all 3 are regarded as top 10 punchers ever.

LISTON
FRAZIER
FOREMAN

I don't think it can be simplified.

All time SR robinson.

 

[Raging_Bull86]

sugar ray robinson

kid gavilan
jake lamotta
bobo olson
carmen basillio
gene fulmer
randy turpin
rocky graziano
just to name a few greats he beat

 

[Raging_Bull86]

sorry forgot about the three names

 

[Guest]

Don't forget Clinton Woods, and if we're including future wins...Joe Calzaghe.

(This is for Roy Jones)

 

[LeedsLad]

Don't forget Clinton Woods, and if we're including future wins...Joe Calzaghe.

(This is for Roy Jones)

lol....:laugh: