Boxing Forum - Boxing Discussion Forums banner
1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,687 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 · (Edited)
So here it goes

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - 120 pts

2. Manny Pacquiao - 104 pts

3. Joe Calzaghe - 97 pts

4. Miguel Cotto - 87 pts

5. Juan Manuel Marquez - 76 pts

6. Israel Vasquez
- 74 pts

7. Kelly Pavlik - 46 pts

8. Rafael Marquez - 37 pts

9. Ivan Calderon - 19 pts

10. Bernard Hopkins - 10 pts


Voting members(11): Mega, DRpugilist, VD, Rotten Apple, Balistik, Brutus, NinjaDude, BigDigga, SweetSugar, Jroc81, Rayman.
Point System:
-10 points for number #1 everytime its mentioned in a list, 9 for #2 and goes on...
-Every fighter gets an extra 1 point for everytime its ever mentioned in a list - why? let me show an exemple: lets suppose Alfonso Gomez gets voted once as number 9, and John Ruiz voted twice as 10. Both would have 2 points, but with the extras Ruiz would get the nod, wich sounds more fair once he was voted by more members.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
25,672 Posts
Thats a good list guys. :thumbsup:
 

·
Wet Beaver Bandit
Joined
·
5,334 Posts
Good job getting Calderon up there. The guy deserves credit.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
249 Posts
Can i add a list? i will remove it if i cant.

1.Mayweather
2.Calzaghe
3.Pacquaio
4.Cotto
5.Vasquez
6.JMarques
7.Pavlik
8.Hopkins
9.Calderon
10.RMarques
 

·
Calvarez
Joined
·
7,453 Posts
My list would be:

1 Mayweather
2 Calzaghe
3 Pacquiao
4 JM Marquez
5 Vasquez
6 Pavlik
7 Cotto
8 R Marquez
9 Calderon
10 Hatton
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
2,091 Posts
i actually believe floyld is 3rd.

manny 1st for his productivity and activity. going up in weight also.

joe calz 2nd because he is getting old but still has stamina/work rate like no other. gone up in weight.

flolyd for retiring/ fighting osscar who ddoesn't pose a threat these days.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,908 Posts
i actually believe floyld is 3rd.

manny 1st for his productivity and activity. going up in weight also.

joe calz 2nd because he is getting old but still has stamina/work rate like no other. gone up in weight.

flolyd for retiring/ fighting osscar who ddoesn't pose a threat these days.
:confused:
 

·
Calvarez
Joined
·
7,453 Posts
i actually believe floyld is 3rd.

manny 1st for his productivity and activity. going up in weight also.

joe calz 2nd because he is getting old but still has stamina/work rate like no other. gone up in weight.

flolyd for retiring/ fighting osscar who ddoesn't pose a threat these days.
I'm not a big fan of Floyd as most will know, but he is UNDISPUTEDLY POUND FOR POUND THE BEST. ;)
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,687 Posts
Discussion Starter · #12 ·
i actually believe floyld is 3rd.

manny 1st for his productivity and activity. going up in weight also.

joe calz 2nd because he is getting old but still has stamina/work rate like no other. gone up in weight.

flolyd for retiring/ fighting osscar who ddoesn't pose a threat these days.
That doesnt make sense at all man..p4p is who you think would win if they were in the same weight class. I mean it doesnt matter how good Joe calzaghe is for his age, what matters is how good he is, just that.

Manny pacquiao has many flaws and there were 2 rounds marquez dominated him, not to mention the compubox statistics slightly favored Marquez, so he cant be the number one the way I see it.
Floyd always scores with tremendous accuracy and barely gets hit with a clean shot,not to mention his handspeed and reflexes are great.
 

·
Calvarez
Joined
·
7,453 Posts
That doesnt make sense at all man..p4p is who you think would win if they were in the same weight class. I mean it doesnt matter how good Joe calzaghe is for his age, what matters is how good he is, just that.

Manny pacquiao has many flaws and there were 2 rounds marquez dominated him, not to mention the compubox statistics slightly favored Marquez, so he cant be the number one the way I see it.
Floyd always scores with tremendous accuracy and barely gets hit with a clean shot,not to mention his handspeed and reflexes are great.
Good points. Marquez clearly beat Pacquiao as well :thumbsup:
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
25,820 Posts
I scored both Pac/Marquez fights a draw. These guys are evenly matched but Marquez went down 4 times in 2 fights and he officially lost so he shouldn't be in the top5 IMO.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,505 Posts
Marquez is borderline top 5 for me. I think a great argument can be made for him being top 5, since you can easily say he beat the #2 P4P fighter twice. With Mayweather gone hes in my top 5.
 

·
Calvarez
Joined
·
7,453 Posts
I scored both Pac/Marquez fights a draw. These guys are evenly matched but Marquez went down 4 times in 2 fights and he officially lost so he shouldn't be in the top5 IMO.
So???????? He made up for it by winning most other rounds. :D
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
i actually believe floyld is 3rd.

manny 1st for his productivity and activity. going up in weight also.

joe calz 2nd because he is getting old but still has stamina/work rate like no other. gone up in weight.

flolyd for retiring/ fighting osscar who ddoesn't pose a threat these days.

agree mate. :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
Good points. Marquez clearly beat Pacquiao as well :thumbsup:
i'd beg to disagree on this. i may submit that this fight may be subject for argument but it cannot lead to the conclusion of manny being defeated by marquez. marquez, in fairness, fought very well in this encounter but having said that, pacquiao still remains better than him... :)
 

·
Calvarez
Joined
·
7,453 Posts
i'd beg to disagree on this. i may submit that this fight may be subject for argument but it cannot lead to the conclusion of manny being defeated by marquez. marquez, in fairness, fought very well in this encounter but having said that, pacquiao still remains better than him... :)
Marquez was the better man.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
19 Posts
So here it goes

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr. - 120 pts

2. Manny Pacquiao - 104 pts

3. Joe Calzaghe - 97 pts

4. Miguel Cotto - 87 pts

5. Juan Manuel Marquez - 76 pts

6. Israel Vasquez
- 74 pts

7. Kelly Pavlik - 46 pts

8. Rafael Marquez - 37 pts

9. Ivan Calderon - 19 pts

10. Bernard Hopkins - 10 pts
I think the list is good. Wish Mayweather didn't retire, I want to see more fights with this guy!
 
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top