[Icantbox]

The mods (or whoever) has their P4P but let's see where we stand on the top ten. We've had enough fights in the last 2 months to bring some clarity to it all.

1-Mayweather
2-Calzaghe
3-Pacquiao
4-Cotto
5-Vazquez
6-Pavlik
7-Ivan Calderon
8-Juan Manuel marquez
9-Wladimir Klitchko
10-David Haye

 

[SugarShane]

There's a certain way to do it to get an overall assessment of everyone's opinion. Come up with a point system where 1 gets 25 2 gets 22 and so on. Then just add every fighters points up to get ONE list from you guys. Good idea dude.

 

[TysonJones]

I really dont think it matters, there are so many biased members on board lol, we'd end up with floyd not being number 1, and that would be so inaccurate its not funny but anywayz to stay on subject, heres my top 5

Mayweather
Pacquiao
Calzaghe
Cotto
Pavlik

These are clearly the best fighters in the sport right now, 4 out of the 5 are undefeated, and Pacquiao imo has only lost once.

 

[ItalianBull]

I'm a little surprised you have kelly in there Lance

 

[TysonJones]

Whys that, Im a big kelly fan, just an even bigger taylor fan, but he beat taylor twice and that imo, puts him right up there with the best of them p4p wise. :thumbsup:

 

[ItalianBull]

Whys that, Im a big kelly fan, just an even bigger taylor fan, but he beat taylor twice and that imo, puts him right up there with the best of them p4p wise. :thumbsup:

nice:thumbsup: it's just I wasn't sure if he was in my top 5 yet. haha

 

[TysonJones]

He should be, the top 5 is easy imo, the rest gets kind of difficult.

 

[Brutus]

Mayweather
Calz
Paq
Cotto
Pavlik
These 5 are the dominant top p4p atm.
Guys up there but not on the above level

Calderon
Vazquez
Jmm
Rm
Wlad
Haye
Margarito
Winky
Casamayor

Mighe be forgetting somone but the top 5 is pretty clear imo.

 

[jroc81]

1 Mayweather
2.Calzaghe
3.Cotto
4.Pacquiao
5.Vazquez
6.JMM
7.Pavlik
8.Dawson
9.Haye
10.Calderon

 

[Megarodon]

#1 - Mayweather
#2 - Calzaghe
#3 - Pacquiao
#4 - Juan Manuel Marquez
#5 - Miguel Cotto
#6 - Israel Vasquez
#7 - Rafael Marquez
#8 - Kelly Pavlik
#9 - Bernard Hopkins
#10 - Shane Mosley

 

[Jake Shaw]

1. Floyd 'Pretty Boy/Money' Mayweather
2. Manny 'Pac-Man' Pacquiao
3. Joe 'The Pride Of Wales' Calzaghe
4. Miguel 'Junito' Cotto
5. Kelly 'The Ghost' Pavlik
6. Israel 'Magnifico' Vasquez
7. Ivan 'Iron Boy' Calderon
8. Rafael Marquez
9. 'Dinimita' Juan Manuel Marquez
10. Bernard 'The Executioner' Hopkins

 

[BALISTIK]

There's a certain way to do it to get an overall assessment of everyone's opinion. Come up with a point system where 1 gets 25 2 gets 22 and so on. Then just add every fighters points up to get ONE list from you guys. Good idea dude.

Good idea. Everyone besides the mods should vote and we'll get all the members opinion in one list.

 

[Megarodon]

Yup we should do that, thatd be interesting

 

[TommyGunn]

Sounds good. :thumbsup:

 

[Guest]

1.Mayweather
2.Calzaghe
3.Cotto
4.Pacman
5.Kelly Pavlik