New Pound For Pound Best list

1872 Views 26 Replies 9 Participants Last post by daveDaboxingfan, Mar 25, 2007

prettyboywho

Discussion Starter · Mar 20, 2007

For Period Ended March 14, 2007
POUND-FOR-POUND
1. FLOYD MAYWEATHER
WELTERWEIGHT
2. MANNY PACQUIAO
JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHT
3. WINKY WRIGHT
MIDDLEWEIGHT
4. JERMAIN TAYLOR
MIDDLEWEIGHT
5. BERNARD HOPKINS
LIGHT HEAVYWEIGHT
6. MARCO ANTONIO BARRERA
JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHT
7. RAFAEL MARQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
8. JOE CALZAGHE
SUPER MIDDLEWEIGHT
9. RICKY HATTON
JUNIOR WELTERWEIGHT
10. SHANE MOSLEY
WELTERWEIGHT

1 - 20 of 27 Posts

SugarShane

· #2 · Mar 20, 2007

Well Barerra lost. I see it was 3/14 though, three days before the fight. I disagree with Shane Mosley being 10. I would put him further up there.

In the next few years Andre Berto will be creeping in to this list.

KNUCKLE UP

· #3 · Mar 20, 2007

I would have Pacman #1 and Winky #2. Another Marquez should now be in there with his win against Barrera. And Taylor is not in my top 10. I think he lost to Hopkins and Winky.

ERIK

· #4 · Mar 20, 2007

prettyboywho said:
For Period Ended March 14, 2007
POUND-FOR-POUND
1. FLOYD MAYWEATHER
WELTERWEIGHT
2. MANNY PACQUIAO
JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHT
3. WINKY WRIGHT
MIDDLEWEIGHT
4. JERMAIN TAYLOR
MIDDLEWEIGHT
5. BERNARD HOPKINS
LIGHT HEAVYWEIGHT
6. MARCO ANTONIO BARRERA
JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHT
7. RAFAEL MARQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
8. JOE CALZAGHE
SUPER MIDDLEWEIGHT
9. RICKY HATTON
JUNIOR WELTERWEIGHT
10. SHANE MOSLEY
WELTERWEIGHT

No Cotto , No J M Marquez???

What about some of the little guys? Like Darchinyan, Calderon ,John :dunno:

Who has Calzaghe beat to be in the top 10 P4P list? 1 win over Lacy gets you in there?

SugarShane

· #5 · Mar 21, 2007

ERIK said:
No Cotto , No J M Marquez???

What about some of the little guys? Like Darchinyan, Calderon ,John :dunno:

Who has Calzaghe beat to be in the top 10 P4P list? 1 win over Lacy gets you in there?

That list is all messed up. Taylor needs to be taken off as well as Calzaghe, and Barerra. Floyd should still be number one and winky 2 and pacman 3! Well maybe pac over winky, he doesn't punch enough. No way pacman over Floyd.

SugarShane

· #6 · Mar 21, 2007

KNUCKLE UP said:
I would have Pacman #1 and Winky #2. Another Marquez should now be in there with his win against Barrera. And Taylor is not in my top 10. I think he lost to Hopkins and Winky.

Yep, JT should definately not even be considered, and yea he definately lost to hopkins and wink.

KNUCKLE UP

· #7 · Mar 21, 2007

If winky beats hopkins then i would then move him to #1 and pacman #2. i don't even know where i'd put floyd in my list. he hasn't proved he is #1. maybe if he beats dlh, mosley, margo or hatton then i can put him #1. until then maybe top 4. have to think about his position.

Sonny Liston

· #8 · Mar 21, 2007

prettyboywho said:
For Period Ended March 14, 2007
POUND-FOR-POUND
1. FLOYD MAYWEATHER
WELTERWEIGHT
2. MANNY PACQUIAO
JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHT
3. WINKY WRIGHT
MIDDLEWEIGHT
4. JERMAIN TAYLOR
MIDDLEWEIGHT
5. BERNARD HOPKINS
LIGHT HEAVYWEIGHT
6. MARCO ANTONIO BARRERA
JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHT
7. RAFAEL MARQUEZ
JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
8. JOE CALZAGHE
SUPER MIDDLEWEIGHT
9. RICKY HATTON
JUNIOR WELTERWEIGHT
10. SHANE MOSLEY
WELTERWEIGHT

Manny should be NUMBER ONE... I cannot express that enough! :thumbsdown:

TommyGunn

· #9 · Mar 21, 2007

that list is poor, floyd shouldn't be #1, the only guy deserving of that is pacman who steps up every time he fights.

heres my current p4p list.

#1. manny pacquio

#2. rafael marquez

#3 winky wright

#4 joe calzaghe

#5 juan manuel marquez

#6 bernard hopkins

#7 shane mosley

#8 ricky hatton

#9 floyd mayweather

#10 jose luis castillo.

See less See more

tyson

· #10 · Mar 21, 2007

my list

#1. floyd maywaether

#2. manny pacquiao

#3 winky wright

#4 juan manuel marquez

#5 jose luis castillo.

#6 joe calzaghe

#7 ricky hatton

#8 Antonio Margarito

#9 M A barrera

#10 Miguel Cotto

See less See more

jabutillurdown

· #11 · Mar 21, 2007

I think that id switch Mayweather with pacquiao and have mosley around fifth or sixth

SugarShane

· #12 · Mar 21, 2007

tyson said:
my list

#1. floyd maywaether

#2. manny pacquiao

#3 winky wright

#4 juan manuel marquez

#5 jose luis castillo.

#6 joe calzaghe

#7 ricky hatton

#8 Antonio Margarito

#9 M A barrera

#10 Miguel Cotto

I like this list but would have Rafael Marquez on it and drop Castillo

KNUCKLE UP

· #13 · Mar 22, 2007

Here is my list after some thought.

1. Pacman
2. Winky
3. Hopkins
4. JM Marquez
5. R Marquez
6. Mosley
7. Floyd
8. Hatton
9. Calzaghe
10. Israel Vazquez
# 10 was a hard one for me. With his fight with Marquez if his nose wasn't broken, he could have given my #5 all he could handle.

See less See more

daveDaboxingfan

· #14 · Mar 22, 2007 (Edited)

Ok ill try it

1. RAFAEL MARQUEZ- JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
2. MANNY PACQUIAO- JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHT
3. Juan M MARQUEZ- JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
4. SHANE MOSLEY- WELTERWEIGHT
5. JOE CALZAGHE- SUPER MIDDLEWEIGHT
6. WINKY WRIGHT- MIDDLEWEIGHT
7. BERNARD HOPKINS - LIGHT HEAVYWEIGHT

KNUCKLE UP

· #15 · Mar 22, 2007

daveDaboxingfan said:
Ok ill try it

1. RAFAEL MARQUEZ- JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
2. MANNY PACQUIAO- JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHT
3. RAFAEL MARQUEZ- JUNIOR FEATHERWEIGHT
4. SHANE MOSLEY- WELTERWEIGHT
5. JOE CALZAGHE- SUPER MIDDLEWEIGHT
6. WINKY WRIGHT- MIDDLEWEIGHT
7. JOE CALZAGHE- SUPER MIDDLEWEIGHT
8. BERNARD HOPKINS - LIGHT HEAVYWEIGHT

This is an interesting list. Don't know how you have Mosley above Winky when he lost to him twice. Your #1 is really questionable also, but I guess thata why its "your" list. Plus you have the same guy for #1 and #3?

daveDaboxingfan

· #16 · Mar 22, 2007

KNUCKLE UP said:
This is an interesting list. Don't know how you have Mosley above Winky when he lost to him twice. Your #1 is really questionable also, but I guess thata why its "your" list. Plus you have the same guy for #1 and #3?

i don't have them in any order i just put the ones that sould be P4P.

TommyGunn

· #17 · Mar 22, 2007

i take it you mean to have juan manuel marquez in instead of rafa marquez twice dave.

daveDaboxingfan

· #18 · Mar 23, 2007

tommygunn said:
i take it you mean to have juan manuel marquez in instead of rafa marquez twice dave.

yep dude.........

daveDaboxingfan

· #19 · Mar 24, 2007

1-Juan M MARQUEZ

2-RAFAEL MARQUEZ

3-MANNY PACQUIAO

4-SHANE MOSLEY

5-JOE CALZAGHE

6-Sam Soliman

7-WINKY WRIGHT

8-BERNARD HOPKINS

See less See more

TommyGunn

· #20 · Mar 24, 2007

daveDaboxingfan said:
1-Juan M MARQUEZ

2-RAFAEL MARQUEZ

3-MANNY PACQUIAO

4-SHANE MOSLEY

5-JOE CALZAGHE

6-Sam Soliman

7-WINKY WRIGHT

8-BERNARD HOPKINS

im surprised you have soliman on your list, he's just lost to mundine who is b-level.

1 - 20 of 27 Posts

This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.