Not really, but in a H2H sense i feel Hatton would beat Rafael Marquez. P4P is always a tricky subject, do you base it on the being the better boxer? How you feel fights between them would go? Accomplishments, records and achievements? I think there is no set term on what a P4P list entails, hence why there is such a difference in opinion.PrettyBoyFloyd said:They are mine. I very RARELY do a pound-for-pound list, but I was able to come up with a definitive one for the first time in a while.
You think Hatton is a better boxer than Rafael Marquez? Not flaming, just wondering.
Here's minesPrettyBoyFloyd said:1.) Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2.) Manny Pacquiao
3.) Miguel Cotto
4.) Joe Calzaghe
5.) Israel Vasquez
6.) Juan Manuel Marquez
7.) Bernard Hopkins
8.) Rafael Marquez
9.) Juan Diaz
10.) Shane Mosley
...Ricky Hatton, Kelly Pavlik, and others...
Cool man. I just can't justify Kelly Pavlik being a top ten boxer at any weight, and in my honest opinion Hatton is NOT a boxer. He has about 50% of the sweet science down and relies on bully tactics for the rest.TysonJones said:I like your sshane but i would replace mosley's with pavlik, and rafael marquez with hatton, just simply because both of these guys lost in their last bout. and hatton and pavlik are undefeated, other than that, i agree 100 percent.