Ok, rate different ATG heavyweight's in their primes on a scale of 1-10 in hand speed, power, accuracy, snap, ring smarts, chin, stamina, heart, agility, defence, combo's, and variety of good punches. I will start.
Fighter---speed---power---accuracy---snap---ring smarts---chin---stamina---heart---agility---defence---combo's---varitey of good punches
Holmes------9------7.5------10-------9.5--------10---------9.5-----9-------10--------9---------8----------8---------------8.5 total-108
Ali---------10------7-------10--------10--------10----------10-----9-------9.5------10---------8----------8---------------7.5 total-109
Marciano----6-------10-------7---------7--------7-----------10------10-------10-------6---------7---------9----------------9 total-98
Frazier-----7-------9--------8---------7--------7------------8------10--------10------7---------8----------9---------------7 total-97
Tyson-------8.5-----9--------9---------8--------7-------------8-------8---------6------8---------9----------10-------------9 total-99.5
Lewis--------8------8--------9---------9--------9.5-----------8-------8.5------9------8.5-------8----------8--------------8.5 total-102
Louis--------8.5----9--------10---------10-------9------------6--------9-------9-------8--------8----------10-------------9 total-105.5
Foreman------7------10-------7----------6--------7------------8--------6--------9-------7.5-----7.5--------8--------------8 total-91
Dempsey------8------9.5------8----------8--------7------------9--------10-------9-------7-------7----------8.5------------8 total-99
Tunney-------9------7.5------9---------9---------9------------8--------9-------9--------8-------8----------7--------------9 total-101.5
I'll do more later. Oh, and I would have given Ali a 10 in heart, but he wanted to quit 2 or 3 times in his corner.
Fighter---speed---power---accuracy---snap---ring smarts---chin---stamina---heart---agility---defence---combo's---varitey of good punches
Holmes------9------7.5------10-------9.5--------10---------9.5-----9-------10--------9---------8----------8---------------8.5 total-108
Ali---------10------7-------10--------10--------10----------10-----9-------9.5------10---------8----------8---------------7.5 total-109
Marciano----6-------10-------7---------7--------7-----------10------10-------10-------6---------7---------9----------------9 total-98
Frazier-----7-------9--------8---------7--------7------------8------10--------10------7---------8----------9---------------7 total-97
Tyson-------8.5-----9--------9---------8--------7-------------8-------8---------6------8---------9----------10-------------9 total-99.5
Lewis--------8------8--------9---------9--------9.5-----------8-------8.5------9------8.5-------8----------8--------------8.5 total-102
Louis--------8.5----9--------10---------10-------9------------6--------9-------9-------8--------8----------10-------------9 total-105.5
Foreman------7------10-------7----------6--------7------------8--------6--------9-------7.5-----7.5--------8--------------8 total-91
Dempsey------8------9.5------8----------8--------7------------9--------10-------9-------7-------7----------8.5------------8 total-99
Tunney-------9------7.5------9---------9---------9------------8--------9-------9--------8-------8----------7--------------9 total-101.5
I'll do more later. Oh, and I would have given Ali a 10 in heart, but he wanted to quit 2 or 3 times in his corner.