everybody's lsit sucks. A guy that is 2-3 his last five fights at 4 is retarded. that's like me claiming the Broncos got screwed out of the super bowl.
put it this way. calzaghe and taylor fights were damn close.
winky well i don't give much credit for. tarver is ok.
i always calculate p4p using all the factors that i know. in terms of win and loses, i always evaluate the opponents. if hopkins beat 10 police men then he wouldn't be in there. he lost to world champs and classy guys and even then it was close.
if i was to put hopkins in with a lot of 160-175 fights, he would beat a lot.
the reason why i always use factors like age, generalship, latest opponents, style, achievemtents in my p4p list is the fact that i can never imagine a feather weight vs a heavy. i mean pacman may be fast at light weight but if he was a heavy he wouldn't be that fast and he would not punch as much.
ps. i forgot to put pavlik at 4 and hopkins at 5. you may still not agree with me but that's my list.