Where should Joe calzaghe be ranked in the p4p list

tyson said:

Where should Joe calzaghe be ranked in the p4p list

this is my p4p list

1. PBF
2. manny Pac
3. Jermain Taylor
4. winky wright
5. Ricky Hatton
6. Joe Calzaghe
7. miguel cotto
8. Bernard Hopkins
9. paul williams
10. a margarito

Click to expand...

:laugh: no barrera no rafa marquez, no wlad. :laugh:

lol. as i said though p4p lists are a mater of opinion. :laugh: paul williams at 9 he aint fought nobody but bums and a 37 year old blew up lightwelterweight sharmba.

rafa and barrera. yes i sopose so tommy.

ill post a mayweather video soon and you can see what he's like under pressure from a b level fighter.

cheerz tommy. Its just i have his whole career on dvd and have seen every fight on him. Come on dude hes awsome. I would love too see hatton body punches destroy him though and think he could do so.

hey tommy i see you have alot of points there. Why not put them points where your mouth is and bet on The mayweather vs hoya fight. i have 1500 points on de la hoya winnig?

im waiting till the day before the fight so i can have about 20,000 to bet on oscar. lol

That sounds good to me. I am goin to try and reach about 10,000 on oscar

NO WHERE he has only been in 1 division if im correct. So no where on my POUND 4 POUND list.

i bet jermain taylor would be on your list though, another u.s fan not relising greatness when they see it. :laugh:

Taylor is not on my list either. He is only a 1 weight class fighter. so no p4p ranking for him.

p4p lists are objective, it doesn't mater how many weight classes you've fought in or if you've just been in one. yeah everybody respects a 2 weight champ but showing dominance in one weight class like hopkins or calzaghe have show greatness also. marvin hagler only fought in one weight class but he's on 99% of peoples lists.

And thats where I separate the "Great fighters" list from the "Pound 4 Pound" list. True you can dominate 1 weight class but what would make you a pound 4 pound fighter?

Hey Taylors on my lis. Hes a class act and will be undefeated for a while. A future star. OK his last fight against ouma wasnt great and his fight against winky wright ended in a draw but hes still learning. Hes geting more experienced and shows good skills in the ring. Theres no one in middleweight that can beat him and in my eyes i see no one in super middle. Calzaghe is going to be a future fight for him and i see taylor winning a UD

Wow Tyson dont let Tommygunn read that post. LOL

prettyboywho said:

Wow Tyson dont let Tommygunn read that post. LOL

Click to expand...

i no mate. lol. tommy will have a say about that but its personaly what i think.

tyson i usualy do respect your opinion but out of taylors last 4 fights he should be 2-2 not 4-0, every boxing fan on planet pluto knows this.

I guess that makes you the only one Tommygunn because there is no people on Pluto and its not a planet anymore. lol

lol, but 2-2 it should be.

Well you know that I think he should be 4-0